How to Choose an Umbrella Company
10 essential questions to ask before signing with any umbrella company — and what the right answers look like.
Last updated: April 2026
With hundreds of umbrella companies in the UK market — and some that are non-compliant or even fraudulent — choosing the right one matters. Use these 10 questions as your checklist.
Are you FCSA or APSCo accredited?
FCSA (Freelancer & Contractor Services Association) and APSCo accreditation means the umbrella company has been independently audited against compliance standards. This is the strongest indicator of a trustworthy umbrella company.
Yes — FCSA Full Member or APSCo Compliance+ member
No — or vague claims about 'compliance' without independent accreditation
What is your weekly/monthly margin?
The margin is your only variable cost. It should be clearly stated upfront with no hidden fees. Typical range is £15–£40/week.
Fixed, transparent margin with everything included
Low headline margin with extra charges for insurance, fast payment, or other services
What professional insurance is included?
Most contractors need Professional Indemnity (PI) and Public Liability (PL) insurance. Good umbrella companies include this in the margin. Inadequate cover could leave you personally exposed.
PI £5m+ and PL £10m+ included in the margin
Insurance not included, or only basic employers' liability
What is your payment frequency and method?
Most contractors are paid weekly or monthly. Understanding when your pay arrives and how (BACS, faster payment) matters for cash flow.
Weekly or monthly, same-day faster payment at no extra charge
Extra charges for fast payment, or only monthly despite weekly contracts
Is there a minimum term or exit fee?
A reputable umbrella company doesn't need to trap you. You should be able to leave at any time without penalty.
No minimum term, no exit fees
Minimum term contracts, notice periods, or exit fees
How do you handle holiday pay?
You are entitled to 5.6 weeks' paid holiday (12.07% of gross). Umbrella companies handle this as rolled-up pay or accrued. You should understand exactly how yours works.
Clear explanation of method (rolled-up or accrued), shown on payslip
Vague explanations, holiday pay not clearly shown on payslip
What pension is provided?
Auto-enrolment is a legal requirement. Contributions should be at least the statutory minimums (3% employer, 5% employee).
Auto-enrolment compliant, clear about contribution rates and pension provider
Vague about pension, inability to confirm employer contribution rate
How do I submit timesheets and invoices?
Good umbrellas have streamlined digital processes for timesheet submission and invoice raising. Clunky processes cost you time.
Online portal or app, quick turnaround from timesheet to payment
Manual email-based processes, slow processing, poor customer service
Can I speak to a real person when I need help?
You'll need support at some point — with payslip queries, tax codes, or agency issues. Good umbrellas are responsive.
Named account manager, phone support, quick email response times
Only email contact, generic responses, slow resolution
Do you promise unusually high take-home pay?
If an umbrella company promises take-home significantly above standard PAYE rates, it is a serious red flag. Non-compliant schemes can lead to large HMRC tax bills.
Take-home matches standard PAYE calculations (use our calculator to verify)
Claims of 85%+ take-home, 'loan' arrangements, complex offshore structures
Verify Any Quote
Use our calculator to verify any umbrella company's take-home quote is correct.
Check the Numbers